Authentic Vietnam and Cambodia: A Journey
“We who have seen war will never stop seeing it. In the silence of the night, we will always hear the screams. So this is our story, for we were soldiers once, and young.”—Joseph L. Galloway
I felt a quiet apprehension entering Vietnam for the first time. Would the Vietnamese still carry resentment toward Americans? After all, more than two million of their people died in a war waged under the banner of American freedom and democracy—meant to halt the spread of Communism. But history has since revealed a different story. The U.S. failed to understand that the Vietnamese were not merely pawns of an ideology. They were fighting, fiercely and stubbornly, for their own independence—against centuries of Chinese, then French, domination.
Was the war always doomed to be a brutal and pointless chapter—divorced from real survival or moral clarity? In The Vietnam War, the powerful documentary by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick, a U.S. Undersecretary of Defense reflects with rare candor: the ground invasion in 1965 was “70 percent to avoid humiliation.” A Marine officer goes further, saying, “You’re killing people to protect your male ego.”
That war still haunts the American soul. Without it, there would have been no draft, no protest movement, no Bob Dylan or Joan Baez, no hippie counterculture. Perhaps just a lot of disillusioned youth experimenting with LSD and rebelling against their parents in quieter ways. In the same documentary, a North Vietnamese veteran offers a piercing insight: “People sing about victory, about liberation. They are wrong. Who won the war and who lost is not the question. In war, no one wins or loses. There is only destruction. Only those who have never fought like to argue about who won and who lost.”
As an Israeli, I can’t help but wonder—is war our fate too? Is it inescapable, woven into the fabric of our national identity? Are we truly doing all we can to challenge that assumption? I often lean toward the view that war is Israel’s tragic destiny—that no real alternatives have yet emerged. But like the Americans in Vietnam, perhaps we, too, are misreading the story. I want to believe we can be wrong—and that being wrong might one day lead to something better. I wish, with all my heart, that Israelis and Palestinians could look at each other the way the Vietnamese and Americans do now: not with hatred, but with a strange, hard-earned kinship.